Puritans in New England (source: National Geographic) |
I did not expect that I would spend so much of 2023 reading about Salem, Massachusetts and the Salem Witch Trials. It was purely accidental that, early in the year, I stumbled upon a whole group of my early American ancestors who lived in and around Salem and experienced that infamous period in time. It has been fascinating to learn the ways in which my family members, and my husband's family members, endured what transpired in Salem in 1692.
I've previously profiled a number of different families in my tree that settled in the towns northeast of Boston in the 1600s, including the Coldham family, the Norwood family, the Stevens family, and the Eveleth family. They were all involved in the Salem Witch Trials. I've also written about my husband's famous ancestor, John Proctor, whose tragic story is told in the American classic, The Crucible by Arthur Miller. Just when I thought I had reached the end of studying this period in time, I found another group of ancestors from Salem, the Moulton family. The events of 1692 are just a small part of their story, which isn't detailed until the end of this post. Let's start much earlier, with my immigrant Moulton ancestor, Robert Moulton.
Robert Moulton
The Moultons were, and continue to be, a well-known family in and around Salem. There is a Moulton Avenue that runs along the North River, just north of downtown Salem. Current U.S. Representative Seth Moulton hails from Salem. There are many Moulton families still in the area, but they would be distant relatives of mine at this point, since my branch of the Moulton tree left Salem for Connecticut in 1636.
The Moulton story in America begins with Robert Moulton, my 11th great-grandfather. Much of what is known (and can be proven) about Robert and his family was compiled into a book titled Moulton Family Ancestors: Immigrants to Salem 1626-1629 by Graham Cocks. Published in 2015, the book is thorough and well-sourced. Much of what I know about the Moulton family came from this book, and while I will quote anything that comes directly from Moulton Family Ancestors, even my broad summarization of the family's history is based in large part on what I learned from Cocks' work. Anyone who is studying the Moulton family should buy a copy of this book.
Robert Moulton was born in England around 1587. Cocks begins the chapter about Robert as follows:
As the chief of a team of shipbuilders sent by the Massachusetts Bay Company in 1629, Robert Moulton was an important man in the early days of Massachusetts. He soon became a freeman, a selectman and a Deputy to the General Court.
Then, eight years after his arrival in Naumkeag, he was disarmed and excommunicated when he stood against both state and church in a dispute over religious beliefs and religious tolerance. Within a couple years he was rehabilitated, though he played a more limited role in public affairs thereafter.
It's important to remember why most of the early colonists came to New England. The Puritans were religious hardliners, who believed that the Church of England was not "pure" enough and practiced a very strict and conservative form of Christianity. Their beliefs were not appreciated in England, and feeling marginalized, they left their homeland in the early 1600s to become the first European colonists in early New England.
They [the Puritans] were religious people with a strong piety and a desire to establish a holy commonwealth of people who would carry out God’s will on earth. In such a commonwealth, they felt, it was the duty of the civil authorities to enforce the laws of religion, thus holding a view almost the opposite of that [later] expressed in the First Amendment. (Free Speech Center, Middle Tennessee State University)
I've written in previous posts about the rigid, Bible-based society established by the Puritans in America, where communities were monitored to ensure no members stepped out of line. Those that did might suffer banishment and humiliation. Robert Moulton has not been conclusively documented as being a Puritan. He was sent to New England in 1629 by the Massachusetts Bay Colony to build ships for the colonists, and might well have been hired for his skill, not because his belief system completely aligned with the Puritans.
Illustration of either the Higginson Fleet or the Winthrop Fleet |
Robert sailed from England on the ship George Bonaventure with a team of six carpenters. The Bonaventure was part of what was known as Higginson's Fleet, a group of approximately 350 colonists who sailed together on five ships. Details from Wikipedia:
Higginson led a group of about 350 settlers (including many of his own congregation) on six ships from England to New England. Because of the ever-present pirate threat as well as the undeclared war with Spain all ships carried armament. The Lyon's Whelp and the "Talbot" left from Yarmouth, Isle of Wight 11 May 1629 and arrived in Salem harbor 29 June 1629. The Higginson Fleet brought with them 115 head of cattle, as well as horses and mares, cows and oxen, 41 goats, some conies (rabbits), along with all the provisions needed for setting up households and surviving till they could get crops in. They would have to build their lodgings for the coming winter from scratch. These were some of the first settlers of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, the main body who would start coming in 1630 on the Winthrop Fleet. The Higginson Fleet set sail on the 1 May 1629, arriving in Salem harbor on the 24 June 1629, and was greeted by a small group of settlers, led by John Endecott.
While they were in route, the Massachusetts Bay Company sent a letter to John Endecott, who was then governor of the colony, stating, "We have sent six shipwrights, of whom Robert Moulton is chief." In another letter a month later, the company gave an inventory of supplies that had been sent with the carpenters, and their goals for the team upon arrival. They wanted a storehouse to be built to house the carpenters' tools and materials, an inventory of those supplies to be taken, and for the carpenters to build three "shallops," small, wooden boats propelled by sails and oars and typically used in shallow waters. Two of these boats would be for company use, and one for company official and future governor, John Winthrop. These boats were to be used for fishing and trading.The ships in the fleet were:
- Talbot (carried 19 cannon) Capt. Benjamin Gonson/Ganson, whose family had long history with the Royal Navy, Sir Admiral Richard Hawkins and Sir Francis Drake.
- George Bonaventure (carried 20 cannon)
- Lyon's Whelp (carried 40 planters + crew + 8 cannon)
- Four Sisters (carried 14 cannon)
- Mayflower (carried 14 guns); a different ship from the Pilgrim's Mayflower
- Pilgrim (small ship with 4 guns that carried supplies only)
An example of a shallop |
Robert and the carpenters arrived in Naumkeag, the Native American name for the settlement that was later called Salem, Massachusetts. Naumkeag was also the name of the indigenous people who lived there. More information about the Naumkeag people, how they interacted with the colonists, and their fate can be found at Salem.org. In Moulton Family Ancestors Graham Cocks describes what Robert and his crew encountered when they arrived at Naumkeag.
We know a little of what Salem was like when Robert Moulton arrived, for Francis Higginson wrote that there were "about halfe a score Houses, and a faire House newly built for the Governour." Including the approximately two hundred men who came with the Higginson Fleet, there were about three hundred planters, about two thirds of whom were in Salem and the remaining hundred in Charlestown.John Winthrop, who was to become the next governor of the area settled by the Massachusetts Bay Company, arrived in 1630 with about 1200 settlers. This increased the population of the area significantly, and there was not adequate housing. Graham Cocks quotes from a letter written at the time regarding conditions in Salem:
Housing was clearly inadequate for the population, so building suitable accommodation before the onset of winter would have been a clear priority. With their carpentry skills, Robert Moulton and his team of six shipbuilders may have helped with that task, though their first priority may have been to build the three shallops...
The multitude set up cottages, booths and tents, about the Town Hill. They had long passage; some of the ships were seventeen, some eighteen weeks a coming. Many people arrived sick of the scurvy, which also increased much after their arrival for want of houses, and by reason of wet lodgings in their cottages; and other distempers also prevailed. And although people were generally very loving and pitiful, yet the sickness did so prevail, that the whole were not able to tend the sick as they should be tended; upon which many perished and died, and were buried about Town Hill.
John Winthrop |
The Blessing, as Winthrop referred to the vessel in his writings, was used to deliver men and soldiers westward, where they built a garrison to protect English settlers from the Dutch and Indians on the Connecticut River. These communities included what would become Chicopee, Springfield, Holyoke and other towns that are still in existence today. If the Governor had not taken these actions, the settlements on the Western Massachusetts border could easily have come under Dutch control. At that time, they held New York and were rapidly extending their reach. In fact, New Amsterdam was the original name of New York City, until the English acquired the island years later. The Blessing of the Bay proved tantamount to settlers’ safety.
The Blessing of the Bay was also pivotal to commerce. Trading and bartering of goods became the first industry of New England where fish and fur were the main items of trade. The Blessing enabled settlers to trade with far-off colonies and would sail as far south as Virginia to acquire goods, such as molasses used to make rum, sugar cane and various other products.
It was also the first ship that was armed to fight pirates and to protect other merchant ships.
There are varying tales illustrating the demise of The Blessing. Some speculate that it was lost in a shipwreck on the inner side of Cape Cod. Others say it sailed off course during a storm on the outer Cape, and still others believe that it mysteriously disappeared off the coast of Virginia.
Meanwhile, Robert Moulton had been active in the civic affairs of Charlestown. He was made a freeman on 18 May 1631 and must have received an allotment of land in that year on the north-east of the peninsula, where the Mystic and Charles rivers join the bay. This area became known as Moulton's Point, and the hill there as Moulton's Hill.
John Cotton |
...the Puritan majority held the view that an individual's salvation is demonstrated by righteous behavior or "good works," while the Antinomians argued that one's spiritual condition had no bearing upon one's outward behavior. However, the debate quickly changed, as the Antinomians began to claim that personal revelation was equivalent to Scripture, under the influence of Anne Hutchinson's teachings, while the Puritan majority held that the Bible was the final authority, taking precedence over any personal viewpoints.
According to R.T Kendall, the doctrines of the Antinomians may be summarized as thus: (1) Faith is the sole evidence of justification. (2) There is no necessary "preparation" for grace prior to salvation. (3) Sanctification is not meant to be a proof of salvation. [Wikipedia]
Edwin Austin Abbey (1852–1911) created this famous illustration of Anne Hutchinson on trial in 1901 |
The church decided to check up on loafers who failed to attend religious service so they planned that each Lord's Day, two men should "walke forth in the time of God's worshippe to take notice of such as either lye about the meeting house... or that lye at home or in the fields" to present them to the Magistrate, and one Sabbath Emmanuel Downing and Robert Moulton were to serve so, while the following Sabbath Robert Moulton and Richard Ingersoll were appointed to the task.
The locations of Moulton, Lincolshire (red star) and Moulton St. Mary, Norfolk (blue star) |
In 1635, there came to Newbury, from Norfolk County, England, two brothers, John and Thomas Moulton. After remaining with the infant colony two years, they joined a party and proceeded to settle in Hampton, N. H. Their lands joined. In 1637, a lad of 17 years named William Moulton, came from Ormsby, Norfolk County, England, with Robert Page and family. These emigrants stopped two years near Moulton Hill, Newbury, and then proceeded to Hampton, N. H., where William Moulton married Page's daughter, Margaret. This William settled upon a farm, adjoining his two brothers, Thomas and John. Several years later, Thomas proceeded to York, Maine, and there made a permanent settlement.There is no mention of Robert Moulton in this paper, indicating to me that the Moulton families in Newburyport and Salem were not related. If there was any relationship between Robert and the other Moultons living in New England at the time, it hasn't been conclusively documented.
Not much is known about Robert Moulton's family life. While still living in England, he married a woman named Alice, whose surname is unknown.
- Robert Moulton, Jr. (b. abt 1607; m. Abigail Goode; d. 1665)
- Dorothy Moulton (b. abt. 1618; m. (1) Abraham Finch (2) John Edwards (3) Richard Tousley; d. abt 1680)
Charles Lyle, executive director of the Webb-Deane-Stevens Museum, says the discovery of wampum suggests that the settlers and natives were trading partners. But, he notes, the natives feared the area’s limited food supply was being threatened by a burgeoning influx of immigrants. “In 1637, Indians attacked Wethersfield and they killed six males, three females and then they abducted the two daughters of the richest guy in town,” he says. Contrary to popular belief, he says, “the Indians weren’t there to slaughter the settlers. They were there to eliminate as much as they could the sustenance of the settlers, their food.” Twenty horses and cattle were also killed in the April 23 attack. “They were trying to send a message to the settlers that maybe they ought to go back” where they came from.
Woodward says the kidnapped girls were then taken in canoes down the Connecticut River and “they were paraded in a taunting manner past the [colonists’] fort at Old Saybrook.” They were later ransomed and returned thanks to Dutch intervention. The colonists retaliated violently to the incident, first declaring war on the Pequot on May 1. “It ultimately led,” Lyle says, “to a big army of early settlers attacking the Pequot village and slaughtering (several hundred) men, women and children” a month later in Mystic. That incident was chosen by the History Channel as one of the “10 Days that Unexpectedly Changed America.”
This engraving depicts an attack by Native Americans on the colony at Wethersfield in 1637. Source: Webb-Deane-Stevens Museum |
“The testimony of Robart Moulton sener who testifith and saith that I waching with Susannah Sheldon sence she was afflicted I heard her say that the witches halled her Upone her bely through the yeard like a snacke and halled her over the stone walle & presontly I heard her Controdict her former: disCource and said that she Came over the stone wall her selfe and I heard her say that she Rid Upone apoole to boston and she said the divel Caryed the poole”
No comments:
Post a Comment